Is Haaland the Premier League's greatest ever goalscorer?

The article initiates a debate on who is the best goalscorer in the Premier League era, with Erling Haaland being a central figure in the discussion. Football writer Alex Keble invites readers to vote on this topic, emphasizing Haaland's current form and comparisons to other legendary players.

Jamie Carragher's statement on Sky Sports, describing Haaland as potentially the greatest goalscorer in English football history, sets the tone for the debate. Haaland's performance in the 2025/26 season supports this claim, with nine goals in seven Premier League matches and 21 goals in 12 games across all competitions for club and country. Highlights include a hat-trick in Norway's 5-0 win over Israel and five goals in an 11-1 victory over Moldova, contributing to a 10-game consecutive scoring streak.

Haaland's statistics are noted as extraordinary, drawing comparisons to Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi at their peaks in Spanish football. Specifically, Messi's longest comparable scoring run of 10 games, achieved twice with Barcelona, is mentioned to contextualize Haaland's achievement.

The article traces Haaland's career progression, starting from his early days at Molde in Norway, where he scored 12 goals in 25 games at age 17. He then moved to Red Bull Salzburg, netting 16 goals in 14 matches, and later to Borussia Dortmund, where he scored 49 goals in 52 Bundesliga matches over two seasons, establishing himself as a globally sought-after striker.

Upon joining Manchester City, Haaland made an immediate impact, breaking the single-season goalscoring record with 36 Premier League goals in his first year. Despite an off season in 2024/25, he maintained high performance with 27 and 22 goals in the subsequent seasons, underscoring his consistent and remarkable contributions to the team.